The short-term rental industry experienced unprecedented growth during the pandemic, attracting real-estate investors in cities like San Diego, Detroit, and Philadelphia. However, the exponential rise in short-term rental listings has sparked debates in cities across the United States and Canada. Leaders in places like Atlanta, San Diego, and Aspen are advocating for regulations to limit short-term-rental activity, while some short-term rental owners are pushing back against government restrictions. As the industry reaches a crossroads, cities and towns are trying to strike a balance between supporting tourism revenue and protecting the rights of property owners and residents.
The Growth of Short-Term Rentals
In the aftermath of COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns, short-term rentals experienced record growth. Airbnb reported an 85% increase in average earnings for hosts in 2021, and by 2022, there were a staggering 1.4 million listings available nationwide. The short-term rental giant even had its first profitable year, taking in $1.9 billion in revenue. However, as the industry boomed, concerns arose about the impact on housing markets and local communities.
Regulations and Pushback
To address these concerns, cities like San Diego and Atlanta implemented regulations to curb short-term rentals. San Diego’s city council adopted an ordinance capping short-term-rental properties at 1% of the local housing stock, aiming to preserve housing for residents and limit the influence of investors.
Similarly, Atlanta passed an ordinance requiring short-term rental hosts to pay a $150 annual fee and provide a copy of the property’s deed and a utility bill. However, enforcement has faced challenges, with only a small percentage of listings complying with the new regulations.
Not all cities have been supportive of short-term rental restrictions. Places like Aspen and Frisco in Colorado have faced opposition from property owners and business owners who fear that regulations could dampen tourism and hurt local economies. In response, some cities have opted for compromise solutions, such as requiring short-term rental landlords to live on the property for part of the year, like in Frisco.
Local Housing Markets and Impact on Communities
As the debate continues, some residents in popular travel destinations, such as Joshua Tree, California, and Dauphin Island, Alabama, have expressed concerns about the rapid growth of short-term rentals in their neighborhoods. They fear that the presence of short-term rentals could lead to various issues, from increased noise disturbances to making housing less affordable for local buyers.
Conclusion
The short-term rental industry faces a critical juncture as cities and towns grapple with how to regulate its rapid expansion. While some cities aim to preserve housing for residents and maintain a sense of community, others prioritize tourism revenue and property owners’ rights. Striking the right balance between the benefits of short-term rentals and their potential drawbacks is crucial to ensure sustainable growth in the industry while addressing the concerns of local communities. As regulations continue to evolve, the short-term rental landscape is likely to experience significant changes in the coming years.
Learn More about Regulations Coming to Connecticut
Steve Schappert Founded, and is the broker at Connecticut Real Estate, Schappert owns The Connecticut Art Gallery and Home & Art Magazine Steve also designed, built, and shipped a zero-energy double-walled home to Germany. Schappert is an abstract painting artist and has painted, renovated and provided energy audits for over 1300 homes.
When it comes to real estate, construction and energy efficiency, Steve Schappert is one of the most sought-after experts in the field. With more than 40 years of experience in these areas, he has become a trusted source for reporters looking for insights on the industry. From helping develop net-zero homes to advising on sustainable building practices, Schappert’s knowledge and expertise is unrivaled. Whether it’s for a news article or an in-depth magazine story, reporters turn to Steve Schappert as a reliable source of information. With his expertise and guidance, they can ensure that their stories are accurate and up-to-date.
In the last year I have been interviewed by ABC News Manhattan, Connecticut Magazine and featured in 2 articles in The Washington Post.
If you are looking for a creative broker that thinks outside the box and has been a recognized expert for over 30 years call or text 203-994-3950